Andrea (portrayed by Sarah Chalke) is a wealthy woman who is willing to pay Becky Conner $50,000 to be her surrogate. Becky is chosen as a result of their strong resemblance– Chalke had replaced Lecy Goranson as Becky from the 6th Season to the 9th Season of the original series. She has a strong dislike of plastic bottles which harm the environment. After Becky gets herself checked out by a Doctor, it is found out that Becky's eggs are too old. This sees very little chances of her being able to have a baby, Andrea thanks her but is left with no choice other than to leave Becky and find someone else to be her surrogate.
The next time Andrea is seen, she has had her baby but expresses regret as the baby is too much effort. It is implied she has remained in contact with Becky since the surrogate situation, but for some reason has blocked Jackie on Facebook.